Safewords & Sensitivity: Dungeons & Dragons 5e Designer Says Players Don't Want "Safety" in TTRPGs
On March 20, 2025, Mike Mearls, one of the architects of modern Dungeons & Dragons, let loose at Gary Con with a scathing critique of "safe" gaming. Posting on X while attending the Lake Geneva convention honoring Gary Gygax, Mearls slammed the idea that younger TTRPG players want risk-free sessions.
"Participation trophies are there to make the parents feel good about themselves. The kids know it’s a show," he wrote, brushing aside the modern wave of session zero protocols, safewords, and curated sensitivity tools. Mearls warned that removing meaningful stakes—like the threat of character death—turns roleplaying into "time-wasting slop."
It was vintage Mearls: part battle cry, part old-school throwback, and it landed in the middle of a TTRPG culture war already simmering thanks to D&D 2024's rocky rollout, shifting audience expectations, and Hasbro's corporate meddling.
Mike Mearls: The Dungeon Master Who Helped Build 5e
Mearls isn't some random grognard yelling at clouds. He's been shaping tabletop games since the late '90s. After freelancing for Unknown Armies and Warhammer adventures, he was hired by Wizards of the Coast in 2005 and quickly became a key voice in D&D development.
He helped launch the much-debated 4th Edition, championed encounter-based combat with Tome of Battle, and then co-led the wildly successful D&D 5th Edition alongside Jeremy Crawford. 5e was a hit: streamlined, flexible, and deeply narrative-focused.
By 2018, Mearls was D&D's Creative Director. But controversy followed. After criticism over his response to abuse allegations in the community, he stepped away from D&D in 2019, later clarifying in 2025 that it was due to philosophical clashes with WotC leadership. He briefly returned in 2020, only to be swept up in Hasbro's December 2023 layoffs.
Now he's at Chaosium as Executive Producer for RPGs, working on new indie projects through his Patreon. But clearly, he's still got plenty to say about D&D's direction.
The Gary Con Rant That Lit Up X
Mearls’ comments were direct:
"Because I'm at Gary Con and feeling salty – I think the idea that younger gamers want a 'safe' game – whatever that means – is utterly wrong."
"The meaning of play comes from the sense of risk. We roleplay because it’s a place where we can experience risk, loss, and defeat without enduring tangible harm."
"The bigger the threat, the more meaning play has to us emotionally and spiritually. Removing it from the game turns it into time-wasting slop."
It wasn't just a hot take—it was a direct shot at an industry shifting toward trauma-informed storytelling, content warnings, and inclusive practices.
Safewords and Sensitivity Readers: The Culture Clash
In recent years, D&D and other major TTRPGs have leaned into safety tools like the X-card, consent checklists, and sensitivity readers. These practices, meant to make games more inclusive and less triggering, have become standard at tables and in published content.
Mearls isn't impressed.
His view clashes with Wizards' current approach—especially after the 2020 backlash over how orcs and drow were portrayed. Sensitivity readers now vet every release, and the 2024 edition reflects that, much to the frustration of some old-school players.
5.5e and the Fallout of One D&D
Mearls' rant also landed as the 2024 edition of D&D—dubbed 5.5e or One D&D—struggles to find its footing.
Despite Wizards claiming it’s the "best-selling D&D product ever," actual data shows the new core rulebooks lagging behind older titles like Tasha's Cauldron of Everything. The Player's Handbook from 2014 topped Amazon charts for years; the 2024 version isn't replicating that magic.
The 2023 OGL debacle damaged creator trust. A 2024 foreword by designer Jason Tondro calling Gygax misogynistic added fuel to the fire. Meanwhile, YouTubers like Esper the Bard are jumping ship, criticizing the brand's corporate tone-deafness.
Mearls’ take isn’t coming out of nowhere—he’s echoing a growing chorus of frustrated players and designers.
What Does It Mean for D&D?
Mearls is drawing a hard line. His comments suggest he sees the soul of D&D not in sanitized, curated sessions, but in high-risk storytelling where failure, danger, and grit are part of the magic.
His critics argue that safety tools let more people enjoy the game—especially marginalized players previously excluded. But his fans say he’s calling out a shift that’s hollowing out the genre.
With 5.5e underperforming and veteran designers like Mearls moving on, the table is wide open for indies, OSR systems, and alt-TTRPGs to step into the void.
Weigh In: Is D&D Losing Its Edge?
Do you side with Mearls' call for risk and realism, or do safety tools make TTRPGs stronger? Is D&D 2024 losing its magic, or just growing up? Drop your thoughts below or ping us on X @DREZZEDNews — I’m here to deliver the facts and hear your unfiltered take on this chaotic campaign.
News compiled by Derek Gibbs and Edgar B.
D/REZZED Gaming News is part of Clownfish TV. Subscribe to our newsletter at http://drezzed.substack.com
D/REZZED provides Balanced and Based Gaming, Pop Culture, and Paranormal News. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of hosts, editors, other contributors, affiliates, sponsors, or advertisers. Our articles are human-edited but may utilize AI assistance for research and grammar. Articles may include affiliate links; we may earn commissions on purchases made through these links. Any products or services received for review are disclosed, as are any sponsored posts.